For Reviewers

 

 

Thank you for considering to serve as a reviewer for our journal. Your expertise and contribution are invaluable to ensuring the quality and integrity of the manuscripts we receive. We greatly appreciate your time and effort in reviewing and providing constructive feedback.

 

 

Reviewer Responsibilities:

 

Review manuscripts assigned to you promptly and within the agreed-upon timeline.


Maintain confidentiality and treat the manuscripts with the utmost professionalism.


Evaluate the manuscript's originality, significance, methodology, and overall quality.


Provide constructive and detailed feedback to help authors improve their work.


Identify any ethical concerns, such as plagiarism or conflict of interest.

 


Reviewer Guidelines:

 

Familiarize yourself with our journal's scope, aims, and publication policies.


Review the manuscript objectively, focusing on its scientific merit and clarity.


Assess the manuscript's structure, organization, and adherence to the journal's guidelines.


Comment on the strengths and weaknesses of the research, methodology, and conclusions.


Offer suggestions for improvement and provide specific and actionable recommendations.

 


Reviewer Reports:

 

Use our provided reviewer report template to structure your feedback.


Summarize your overall assessment of the manuscript, highlighting its strengths and weaknesses.


Provide clear and constructive comments on different aspects of the manuscript.


Clearly differentiate between major and minor issues and suggest revisions accordingly.


If necessary, provide additional comments to the editor to assist in the decision-making process.

 


Confidentiality and Conflict of Interest:

 

Maintain the confidentiality of the manuscript and any related information.


Declare any potential conflicts of interest that could compromise your objectivity.


If you feel unable to review a manuscript due to conflicts of interest or lack of expertise, notify the editor promptly.

 


Timely Completion:

 

Reviewers are kindly requested to complete their reviews within the agreed-upon timeframe.


If you require an extension or have any concerns about meeting the deadline, inform the editor as soon as possible.

 


Acknowledgment:

 

Your contribution as a reviewer is highly appreciated and will be acknowledged accordingly.


If you would like to receive recognition for your reviews, please let us know, and we will credit you accordingly.


We sincerely thank you for your dedication to the peer-review process. Your expertise and insights play a crucial role in maintaining the quality and integrity of the research published in our journal. If you have any questions or need further assistance, please contact our editorial office at [Contact Us].

 

 

Best regards,

 

Instrumentation Editorial Team




Copyright © 
Address: No.79 Beiheyan Street, Dongcheng District, Beijing China, 100009    E-mail: instrumentation@cis.org.cn
Technical support: E-Tiller(Beijing) Co.,Ltd.